DPI Home | Contact Us | About Us | Search:
Department of Primary Industries  
Information Notes home Printer Friendly Version

Willows along watercourses: managing, removing and replacing

LC0121
Compiled by the Albury/Wodonga Willow Management Working Group
December, 1998

To view the Adobe Acrobat file, you will need the
Adobe Acrobat reader.
LC0121.pdf(PDF 117 kb)

This Landcare Note describes methods of replacing willows along watercourses.

Introduction

If we want to ensure the continued stability, habitat value and water quality of our rivers and creeks it is essential that land owners carefully manage the growth and spread of willows. Effective management of willows along watercourses involves regular maintenance of existing stands and removal of those trees that threaten stream stability, spread abundantly or do not control erosion. This Note outlines the best management practices for maintaining, removing and replacing willow trees along watercourses as a guide for land owners.

Maintaining willows along watercourses

Timely and regular willow maintenance will reduce the need for stream management and environmental problems associated with willows. Activities that should be carried out on a regular basis include:
1.
    Regular inspections of willow lined watercourses after floods to:
  • Identify and remove logs or branches that have lodged in the area that may develop into new trees.
  • Identify and organise the removal and replacement of trees that have fallen into the stream.
  • Identify and organise the removal and replacement of trees that are encroaching on the stream and growing in the stream bed.
2.
    Regular inspections of willow lined watercourses during spring months to:
  • Identify species that have potential to spread by seed so they can be removed before they release seeds.
  • Determine whether seedlings are developing on the stream bed or bank or on sand/gravel islands so they can be removed and replaced before they grow larger and become more difficult to handle.
3.
    A yearly lopping/pruning program for all willow trees that remain along the watercourse so that:
  • branches do not grow large and hang over the stream, catching debris during high flows;
  • large, top-heavy trees are prevented from toppling; and
  • increased sunlight is able to reach beneath willow canopy, allowing native grasses and shrubs to regenerate.
When lopping/pruning willow trees, it is essential the branches are removed from the site so they do not regenerate in that area or further downstream if they are swept away with subsequent high flows. The success of lopping programmes is dependent on the care taken to ensure that lopped branches and twigs are removed from the area.

Removing willows along watercourses

Where willow trees are causing stream instability, spreading by seed or broken branches, or serving no erosion control purpose, their removal and replacement is recommended. Before proceeding however, it is essential that the impacts on the stream of removing the willows are carefully considered. Indiscriminate removal without careful planning can cause significant problems.

Please note:
  • Any large scale willow removal and replacement programme should be carefully planned with advice from staff at your local Catchment Management Authority Officers are available to assist in planning and advising on willow removal and replacement suitable for your situation.
  • If possible, willow roots should be left undisturbed. Remove only tree branches and trunks and plant around them with indigenous stock.
  • If possible, trees should be killed before they are physically removed.
  • Any large scale willow removal programme should only be carried out in stages over several years.
  • Willow removal on outside bends or in streams which are actively deepening or widening should only be carried out under supervision of trained staff from Catchment Management Authority.
  • All willow removal programmes should include follow-up visits to ensure successful treatment and to remove any twigs or branches washed from upstream lodging and regenerating in the area.
  • All willows removed should be replaced with more suitable indigenous trees, shrubs and grasses to ensure continued bank stability and stream health.
  • Willow removal programs should commence at the most upstream area and gradually work in a downstream direction.
There are three different techniques for replacing willows. The suitability of one method over another will depend on the site, the number and type of trees to be removed and the potential risk of triggering erosion.

Removal techniques

Organic methods
This method kills the tree slowly, leaving the roots intact minimising the risk of erosion. The method is labour intensive but has less detrimental impacts on the surrounding environment.

To remove willows using organic methods:
  • Cut down the tree leaving a stump about ½ to 1 metre high. (Stack all lopped timber well above flood height in a dry position. Burning twelve months later may be required if stems are not dead).
  • Immediately chop up the top of the freshly cut stump with an axe using vertical strokes. This creates hollows that allow rainwater and pathogens to invade the heartwood of the tree.
  • Plant indigenous trees shrubs and grasses.
  • Follow up on several occasions at two monthly intervals. Re-chop the stump, prune any new shoots and remove any branches left behind that may reshoot. After six months or so, the tree will become stressed and should eventually die.
  • Allow the stump and roots to rot away gradually, without removing the root system.

Diagram: A chopped stump

Figure 1. A chopped stump

Poisoning methods
When the organic method is unsuitable, willow poisoning can be undertaken using a suitable glyphosate herbicide. Ensure that the use is listed on the label, and that label instructions are followed.

The preferred method for using herbicides is ringbarking and stem poisoning, as it is low risk in terms of herbicide contamination and it kills the tree without the physical removal of branches and roots. In some circumstances, however, this method is unsuitable and other methods such as lopping and stump painting or spraying tree foliage may be used.

You should read the product label and follow all label instructions carefully before using any herbicide. Willow removal using herbicide needs to be undertaken with extreme caution so as not to harm the user or surrounding environment. When spraying adjacent to waterways it may be necessary to seek approval from the Environment Protection Authority.

Ringbarking and stem poisoning
Herbicide treatment can be applied through injecting or spraying herbicide into the sapwood of the tree. Only use herbicides that are registered for such activities (check the label for this before purchase).

The general procedures are:
  • Choose a dry day in early Autumn.
  • With an axe/machete, ringbark the tree making a series of cuts about 50 mm wide around the entire circumference of the stem (below the first branches or around each of the lower stems). The cuts need to penetrate the sapwood directly beneath the bark but should not enter the heartwood of the tree. Angle the cuts so that the herbicide does not run out.
Diagram: Ringbarked stump

Figure 2. Ringbarked stump

  • Inject/spray registered herbicide into the cuts using a syringe (needle removed) or a sheep/cattle drench pack. This must be done immediately after the cuts are made (ie. within seconds).
  • Monitor the tree in spring for signs of growth. If reshooting occurs, re-cut and apply herbicide again. Remove any stray branches.
  • Leave tree to gradually disintegrate.
  • Protect and rehabilitate the area with fencing. Plant suitable indigenous trees, shrubs and grasses.
Lopping and painting the stump
Where ringbarking and stem poisoning are not possible, herbicide treatment can be applied by lopping the tree and painting the stump immediately with herbicide (check the label before purchase to ensure herbicide is registered for this type of use).

The general procedures are:
  • Choose a dry day just before leaf fall (early Autumn). Lop the tree trunks, leaving a stump ½ - 1 metre high. (Stack all lopped branches and broken twigs well above flood height for burning in twelve months.)
  • Paint the freshly cuts stump immediately with herbicide, taking care not to spill the herbicide and damage the surrounding area.
  • Monitor the tree in spring for signs of growth. If reshooting occurs, apply herbicide again. Remove any stray branches.
  • Leave the stump to die, allowing it to rot and disintegrate gradually.
  • Protect and rehabilitate the area with fencing. Plant suitable indigenous trees, shrubs and grasses.
Hand spraying
If stems are too small to be chopped and poisoned, the foliage can be hand-sprayed. Check the label before purchase and only use a herbicide that is registered specifically for such a purpose. It is advisable to discuss this course of action with your local Environment Protection Authority Office, as approval may be required.

Physical methods
When the removal of entire willow trees along a watercourse can be undertaken without the risk of triggering erosion (i.e. in small streams or on an inside bend of a watercourse), or when the purpose of willow removal is to reduce sedimentation problems in a stream, physical removal methods can be used, although extreme care must be taken. Physical methods include:

Hand pulling of small trees
Trees less than 1 metre tall can usually be removed by hand. Simply hold the tree at its base and gently pull the roots from the soil. Make sure that all stems (with buds) have been removed with the trunk and none remain in the soil to re-sprout. If the willows have developed from seed, it will be relatively easy to hand-pull the roots of small trees from the ground. If the willows have sprouted from the branch or twig of a parent tree, the root system of the tree will be attached to this branch or twig. It is essential that the branch and all the roots growing from it are removed.

Using machinery for larger trees
If the trees are large and can not be hand pulled, an excavator may need to be used.

Physical removal should only be carried out in areas where there is no risk of creating erosion. If there is a risk, use organic or herbicide methods outlined in this Note, and carry out the removal and replacement in stages over time.

The general procedure for physical removal using machinery is:
  • Ringbark and poison the stems in early Autumn, as outlined above.
  • Monitor in spring for signs of tree growth.
  • If poisoning is successful, remove tree trunk and roots with excavator, being careful to cause minimal disturbance to surrounding soil.
  • Stack all debris well above flood height, ready for burning in twelve months, if required.
  • Inspect the removal site and clean up any remaining branches, twigs or roots to prevent reshooting.
  • Inspect site again in late spring and remove any branches, twigs and re-shooting roots.
  • Protect and rehabilitate the area with fencing. Plant suitable indigenous trees, shrubs and grasses.
Further information and action
Before any willow removal works are undertaken, the River Management Group of the Catchment Management Authority must be consulted. These Landcare Notes on willows are provided as a guide only, and should be used in conjunction with on-ground advice from any of the following:
  • Catchment Management Authority (the River Management Group)
  • Department of Sustainability and Environment, Victoria
  • Greening Australia
  • National Herbarium. Royal Botanic Gardens, Melbourne.
  • Environmental Consultants.
See the following related Landcare Notes:
  • LC0117: Willow identification guide
  • LC0118: Willows along watercourses: an introduction
  • LC0119: Willows along watercourses: their impact compared to natives
  • LC0120: Watercourse revegetation using indigenous plants
Acknowledgments

The Working Group thank Geoff Carr - Ecology Australia, Ed Thexton - Riparian Australia and Ross Hardy - ID&A for their comments.
The Albury/ Wodonga Willow Management Working Group consists of: Clare Purtle, DLWC, Albury; Fleur Stelling, DPI Wodonga; Denis Martin, Greening Australia, Beechworth; Terry Grossman, Goulburn Broken CMA; Judy Frankenberg, CFM Consulting; Susan Campbell, CFM Consulting, and Chris Dwyer, ID & A Pty. Ltd. Wangaratta.

This note replaces note number TG0021.

The advice provided in this publication is intended as a source of information only. Always read the label before using any of the products mentioned. The State of Victoria and its employees do not guarantee that the publication is without flaw of any kind or is wholly appropriate for your particular purposes and therefore disclaims all liability for any error, loss or other consequence which may arise from you relying on any information in this publication.


Page Top